Gone in 60 seconds: How the Connection Gap is costing loyal customers?

Published November 16, 2026
Davey Rennie


Want to listen instead in DavyAI? - 6 Min listen Available

Every single dollar of household spending is under the microscope. With rate rises and inflation, Australians are looking at the brands we need vs want and judging their worth, starting with the dollar value. For me, more than four years as a loyal customer ended in two conversations – one with a bot and one across a store counter. The problem wasn't just the price. It was a promise nobody had been trained to keep. I'd stayed for so long because I bought the promise: quality you can count on and a brand that looks after you. So, when my bill didn't move but the competitor’s offer did, I did what any loyal customer facing cost pressures would. I asked for a pricing review.

First, I got the AI response. Polite, quick and completely unmoving. The best it could offer was $5 off a month, still considerably higher than a competitor providing a superior service.

So, I went into a store to talk to a human. Surely a person would see the tenure, the spend, the value of keeping me. The best they could do was move me to the lowest plan, still about 30 per cent more than its closest competitor charges. The response was essentially a polite, “Tough, mate, that's the best I can do.” My daughter laughed. I shrugged. In the 60 seconds it took to reach the car, I had switched to a competitor, saving $50. Two conversations. Two different systems. The same answer. Thanks for your loyalty, there's the door.

I'm not naming names, because it doesn't really matter who it was. It's a cracker business investing seriously in AI across customer service. Frankly, I could tell the same story about half the brands in my wallet. This isn't one company's problem. It's systemic, and it's costing Australian brands far more than one grumpy agency CEO.

Finder estimates Australians paid $6.7 billion in loyalty tax on everyday household services in 2025. Every dollar of that is a customer being told that staying doesn't pay. Eventually they do the maths. I did it in a minute.

Here's what struck me. The machine and the human gave me different numbers, but they were running the same playbook. Both had been trained, one on data and one on company scripts and KPIs, to treat me as a cost to manage rather than a relationship worth keeping.

That isn't a failure of AI. It's a failure of what we teach it.

Most marketing budgets still point at the front door. Around 70 per cent goes on acquisition, including switching offers and shiny new customer pricing. Meanwhile, the people and systems looking after existing customers are measured on handle time and margin protection. Then we act surprised when loyalty leaks out the bottom of the bucket.

We've built an economy where the best deal you'll ever get from a brand is the day you join. After that, the relationship only gets dearer. If a mate treated you like that, you wouldn't call them a mate for long.

This is what we call the Connection Gap: the distance between what a brand promises, what it knows about a customer, and what that customer experiences. It appears when advertising says you matter, but service treats you like a number. When years of data exist, but every conversation starts anew. When a loyalty program records the relationship without recognising it.

The gap is rarely caused by one broken interaction. It forms between the systems, teams and decisions that were never designed to work as one. Marketing acquires the customer. CRM communicates with them. Service resolves the problem. Finance protects the margin. Each may be doing its job, but the customer experiences one disconnected brand.

That is where commercial value leaks out. The customer has already been won. But when intelligence, experience and authority fail to connect at the moment that matters, the relationship resets to zero and the brand pays to replace someone it had already acquired.

There are only a handful of moments where a customer decides to stay or go. A pricing review is one. It's a customer putting their hand up and asking for a reason to stay. That should be the smartest conversation a brand ever has.

The AI should know my tenure, my spend, what I'd cost to replace, and what a competitor would offer me tomorrow. The human should have the authority to act on it. Instead, the AI had a $5 ceiling and the human had a plan menu. Neither cared about tenure, future loss of earnings, or the compounding cost of new customer attraction. None of this needs a moonshot. It needs brands to direct the same smarts they use to win customers at keeping them. Three places to start:

  • Price the relationship, not the plan. Know the customer’s lifetime value and the cost of replacing them. Then give your agents, human and machine, the room to act. A discount that keeps a customer for three more years is the cheapest acquisition you'll ever make.
  • Train the machines on retention, not just resolution. If your AI is measured on calls closed, it will close calls. Sometimes, that means customers closing their accounts too. Measure it on customers kept. And have your people apply the same measure.

Make the promise and the experience match. If your brand says it looks after customers, the retention desk is where that promise gets tested. Marketing and customer service need the same brief and the same measure of success.

Every brand makes a promise. The ones customers stay with are the ones that keep it, especially when it costs them something.

More than four years of loyalty gone in 60 seconds. Not because a competitor out-marketed them, but because nobody I dealt with, human or machine, had been trained to keep me or care.

Davy Rennie is chief executive officer of Digitas Australia.

Click below for The Australian article